A soft veil of smoke slowly settles over the darkness. Cinnamon and black pepper sharpens the silhouette, dry wisps of elemi and incense unfold, rosemary anchors. Leather, woods and earthy tones seep in with silent depth. By the end, a restrained warmth lingers like an afterglow. All Black reveals without showing.
Best Promise by Frederic Malle Editions de Parfums Alternatives & Similar Perfumes
Promise by Frédéric Malle is an oriental floral fragrance that opens with crisp apple and vibrant pink pepper, layered with herbal rosemary and warm saffron. The heart reveals a rich blend of cloves and Turkish rose, while the base combines earthy vetiver, patchouli, castoreum, and labdanum with a smooth ambroxan touch. This composition balances spicy and floral facets with a subtly animalic depth, ideal for those seeking a sophisticated, complex scent with warmth and freshness in equal measure.
Grande Ile by Nissaba £125.00
- Key notes:
- amber
- cloves
- incense
- patchouli
- pink pepper
- vanilla
- Aromagroups:
- spicy
- woody
Grande Ile blends the bounty of Madagascar — vanilla, pink pepper berries and black pepper — into a sensual and comforting spicy amber. This award-winning scent blends a warm ambery accord with clove, caramel nuances and a rich woody bouquet. Contrasting notes of dry cedar, creamy vanilla, and resinous touches create depth and intrigue. Grande Ile’s enveloping trail unfolds gently on the skin, revealing evolving facets throughout the day. Depending on who you ask, this intriguing beauty moirés between Oriental lilies, a vanilla sauna, and a smoky souk.
Experimentum Crucis by Etat Libre d'Orange £200.00
- Key notes:
- apple
- musk
- patchouli
- rose
- Aromagroups:
- aromatic
- floral
- woody
A rapturous rose, apple and patchouli perfume with a lick of honey. But the joyfully fresh effect of the composition is only part of the story. Experimentum Crucis has the most extraordinary projection and longevity, as well as a novel multidimensional architecture. As you wear it, scented castles of Experimentum Crucis form in the air, creating an invisible sanctuary for you and all who smell you.
Ta’if by Ormonde Jayne £195.83
- Key notes:
- amber
- pink pepper
- rose
- saffron
- Aromagroups:
- floral
- woody
Ta´if is an intoxicating and audacious rose scent from the town of Ta´if which sits above the shores of the Red sea and overlooks the Arabian desert. This perfume dislikes daylight preferring dusk, the night, parties, promises and assignations. It is an opulent composition which makes a bold entrance and is confident enough to sweep everyone else to one side – a real belle of the ball.
Almond Suede by Arquiste £162.50
- Key notes:
- almond
- leather
- neroli
- rosemary
- saffron
- suede
- Aromagroups:
- green
- leather
An addictive and sophisticated gourmand balancing almond marzipan and suede leather inspired by Medieval Andalusia, the city of Córdoba and almond sweets. A must try for gourmand lovers.
California by Ampersand £50.00
- Key notes:
- apple
- magnolia
- rose
- sandalwood
- Aromagroups:
- citrusy
- floral
California is a land of abundance: sunshine, flowers and fruits. The fragrance is a sunny swirl of magnolia, apples and lemons, all of which flourish in this west coast wonderland. Sandalwood and musk bridges the flora to the skin, turning you into a delivery system for smiles.
Hanamizake (Watching Sakura & Drinking Sake) by J-Scent £101.67
- Key notes:
- apple
- pear
- raspberry
- rose
- Aromagroups:
- floral
- fruity
Hanamizake refers to drinking Japanese sake underneath the cherry blossom trees while petals slowly flutter into your cup. The aroma of cherry blossoms and ginjo sake dances tipsily into the last musk note, summoning this serene hanami (cherry blossom viewing) experience.
I am Trash | Les Fleurs du Dechet by Etat Libre d'Orange £129.17
- Key notes:
- apple
- rose
- Aromagroups:
- floral
Perfumer: Daniela Andrier (Givaudan)
All listed notes were subjected to an upcycling extraction process. What previously would be discarded was distilled again.
Pulp olfaction: waste not, discover new smells.
According to ELdO this is their Secretion Magnifiques which grew up and use the power of shock and eccentricity to draw attention to really important matters: environment and ethical consumption.
Upcycled or zero-waste notes in I am trash: rose neo-absolute, apple essense, Atlas cedarwood, sandalore, akigalawood, iso-e-super...
The resulting fragrance is a very pleasant perfume abstraction in which fruity vibes meet gently floral hints before going transparent woody. But still beware of Etat Libre d’Orange also mischievously revisiting the salty messy splutter of Secretions Magnifiques now and then in this formula.
The Sniff on I am Trash by Etat Libre d'Orange:
"[it] opens with the most beautiful and realistic apple note and it’s an utter delight. This apple smells really ripe, outdoorsy and fresh. When smelling it we were immediately transported to an allotment, picking up windfalls which are a bit battered and bruised in places but still mostly fine. I Am Trash smells like real apples resplendent with imperfections, rather than the perfect, sterile, waxy cold-storage apples you can buy in supermarkets which barely smell of anything at all."
Lamar by Kajal £141.67
- Key notes:
- amber
- apple
- magnolia
- rose
- vanilla
- Aromagroups:
- edible
- floral
- fruity
In Arabic, Lamar means “liquid gold”, the legendary potion long sought by alchemists in search of immortality. This generous fruity-floral embraces the eternity of living in the moment. In creating Lamar, perfumer Mark Buxton said, “My inspiration was to create a rich, natural, warm, long lasting fragrance, by using high quality natural products. This gives a feeling of walking through a bed of roses or a jasmine field – very feminine and sensual.” Lamar opens with a festival of berries, apple and pineapple. The heart notes glow with jasmine sambac, Turkish rose, Bulgarian rose and magnolia. Vanilla, musk and amber supply the softest landing.
All Black by Insenf £104.17
- Key notes:
- black pepper
- castoreum
- gaiac / guaiac wood
- incense
- rosemary
- tobacco
- Aromagroups:
- aromatic
- leather
Boar by Wolf Brothers £100.00
- Key notes:
- apple
- mushroom
- smoke
- vetiver
- Aromagroups:
- leather
- unconventional
- woody
The intelligent and devious and boar strides confidently under the forest canopy. Hunger fuels his progress. Apples, fallen leaves and mushrooms swirl in the atmosphere around him. His fur is perfumed by the deep green conifer and galbanum. The fragrant blend of leather, vetiver, and truffle denote the damp moss, sweat and scratched bark.
About Promise by Frederic Malle Editions de Parfums
- How does Promise by Frédéric Malle differ from these similar perfumes?
- Promise combines oriental floral notes with a complex balance of bright apple, spicy pink pepper and saffron, and a rich animalic base including castoreum and labdanum. Many similar fragrances focus on subsets of these notes but often omit the full layering of spice, floral, fruity and animalic elements that define Promise’s unique character.
- Which fragrances here share the rose note found in Promise?
- Several fragrances share rose with Promise, including Experimentum Crucis, Ta’if, California, Hanamizake, I am Trash, and Lamar. Each uses rose within different accords, from fresh and fruity to warm and sweet, reflecting varied interpretations of the floral note.
- Are there fragrances listed that emphasise the spicy aspects of Promise?
- Yes, Grande Ile and Ta’if highlight pink pepper and cloves or saffron, emphasising the spicy facets. All Black also brings a spicy and smoky edge through black pepper and castoreum, though with a darker tone than Promise.









